James Duncanson, 1880-1883
Merlin C. Harris, 1884-1885, 1898-1919
Norris M. Grist, 1886-1887
Richard B. Wilkinson, 1888-1889
Fountain Huffman, 1890
Stilleo C. Still, 1891-1892
Myron Chamberlin, 1893-1895
Edward E. Heiser, 1896
William R. Gladman, 1897
William Heynen, 1920-1949
William D. Denholm, 1950-1966, 1968-1969
Robert Alex Visocsky, 1967
Harry Duane Larison, 1970-1973
John R. Williams, 1974-1981
Ervel F. Cleaver, 1982-1986
Anthony Benjamin Swenson, 1987-1994, 1996-1999
Willard J. Howland, 1995
John William Evans, 1999-2000
James Lee Lasher, 2001
Joseph Clinton Smith, 2002-2004
David Franklin Kinzie, 2005-